Home / Stocks / ERIE

Erie Indemnity (ERIE, Property & Casualty Insurance) Stock Valuation & Fair Value Significantly overvalued

Erie Indemnity (ERIE, Property & Casualty Insurance) trades at a blended P/E of 21.6, about 20% below its historical normal valuation, with a forward growth estimate of 17.5% and a PEG of 1.23. Analysts' one-year estimates have been hit 36% of the time.

No quality score is published for this company, which is normal for insurers, banks and REITs. This rating reflects valuation, forecast return and analyst accuracy only. Ratings that cite business quality require one.

DATA AS OF 2026-08-28
Blended P/E
21.6
Normal P/E
27.1
PEG
1.23
Fwd growth
17.5%
Div yield
2.2%
RSI (14)
56.6
Neutral

Valuation flags

Verdict history

tickerseer's rating moved from fairly valued (2026-06-03) to significantly overvalued (2026-08-28).

Price and rating by weekClose moved +28.5 percent from 2026-06-03 to 2026-08-24, with 4 rating changes over 23 recorded weeks.2026-06-03: Fairly valued, close 206.06 (recalculated)2026-06-10: Trading above fair value, close 230.66 (recalculated)2026-06-14: Trading above fair value, close 225.38 (recalculated)2026-06-16: Trading above fair value, close 224.36 (recalculated)2026-06-21: Trading above fair value, close 219.88 (recalculated)2026-07-02: Significantly overvalued, close 257.77 (recalculated)2026-07-06: Significantly overvalued, close 255.67 (recalculated)2026-07-09: Significantly overvalued, close 247.81 (recalculated)2026-07-12: Significantly overvalued, close 251.81 (recalculated)2026-07-13: Significantly overvalued, close 247.17 (recalculated)2026-07-14: Significantly overvalued, close 238.47 (recalculated)2026-07-20: Trading above fair value, close 225.01 (recalculated)2026-07-22: Trading above fair value, close 210.86 (recalculated)2026-07-25: Trading above fair value, close 223.55 (recalculated)2026-07-27: Trading above fair value, close 228.26 (recalculated)2026-07-31: Significantly overvalued, close 242.04 (recalculated)2026-08-03: Significantly overvalued, close 242.042026-08-07: Significantly overvalued, close 252.58 (recalculated)2026-08-10: Significantly overvalued, close 252.582026-08-14: Significantly overvalued, close 255.99 (recalculated)2026-08-17: Significantly overvalued, close 255.992026-08-21: Significantly overvalued, close 264.85 (recalculated)2026-08-24: Significantly overvalued, close 264.852062652026-06-032026-08-24
Attractively valuedFairly valuedAbove fair valueLarger dot: a stronger reading

Not every point was recorded live. Points marked recalculated apply today's valuation rules to the metrics tickerseer archived that week.

2026-06-03P/E 19.0-30%Fairly valued
2026-06-10P/E 19.7-27%Trading above fair value
2026-06-14P/E 19.7-27%Trading above fair value
2026-06-16P/E 19.7-27%Trading above fair value
2026-06-21P/E 19.7-27%Trading above fair value
2026-07-02P/E 21.4-21%Significantly overvalued
2026-07-06P/E 22.2-18%Significantly overvalued
2026-07-09P/E 22.2-18%Significantly overvalued
2026-07-12P/E 21.5-21%Significantly overvalued
2026-07-13P/E 21.5-21%Significantly overvalued
2026-07-14P/E 21.5-21%Significantly overvalued
2026-07-20P/E 19.3-29%Trading above fair value
2026-07-22P/E 19.3-29%Trading above fair value
2026-07-25P/E 18.9-30%Trading above fair value
2026-07-27P/E 18.9-30%Trading above fair value
2026-07-31P/E 19.8-27%Significantly overvalued
2026-08-03P/E 20.4-25%Significantly overvalued
2026-08-07P/E 21.4-21%Significantly overvalued
2026-08-10P/E 21.2-21%Significantly overvalued
2026-08-14P/E 21.5-21%Significantly overvalued
2026-08-17P/E 21.5-21%Significantly overvalued
2026-08-21P/E 21.9-19%Significantly overvalued
2026-08-24P/E 22.1-18%Significantly overvalued
2026-08-27P/E 22.1-18%Significantly overvalued
2026-08-28P/E 21.6-20%Significantly overvalued ← now

Frequently asked questions

Is Erie Indemnity stock overvalued?

At a blended P/E of 21.6 versus its historical normal P/E of 27.1, Erie Indemnity trades about 20% below its typical valuation, with a PEG of 1.23 on 17.5% forward growth. tickerseer currently rates it significantly overvalued.

What is Erie Indemnity's fair value and PEG?

Erie Indemnity trades at a blended P/E of 21.6 against a historical normal P/E of 27.1, a PEG of 1.23, and a forward growth estimate of 17.5%.

Has tickerseer's rating of Erie Indemnity changed?

tickerseer's rating moved from fairly valued (2026-06-03) to significantly overvalued (2026-08-28).

Industry: Property & Casualty Insurance. Create a free account to see the full analysis: the SeerAI score, valuation history, and the AI research note. Options setups and metric history are part of the paid plans.

See the full analysis →🔔 Track ERIE free: valuation & earnings alerts

Get the free weekly earnings preview

One email each Monday with the week's named earnings setups, the reasoning, and what settled last week. Strikes and sizing stay in Premium.

It's free, and you can unsubscribe any time. Educational content, not investment advice.