TRACK RECORD
Week of Sep 21, 2026
Settled options ideas entered during this week, scored against
the stock's actual close around expiration. Every call is here, win or
loss. Open Why this call under any of them to read how it was
picked and, where it was recorded, what the analysis said at the
time.
DATA AS OF 2026-09-26
Overall Win Rate
50%
2W / 2L · 4 settled calls
Bear Call Spread
100%
2W / 0L
- Market context that week
SPY 761.69 (20-day MA 762.50, below) · QQQ 721.45 (20-day MA 713.24, above). At least one index sits below its 20-day moving average, so the macro gate is not in force this week: a bear spread does not need an explicit fundamental catalyst on top of its valuation case.
- Policy in force that week
12 lessons were active that week.
COSTBear Call SpreadBearishTier 2 - Strikes
- $932.34 / $945.79 modeled
- Entered
- 2026-09-24
- Expiry
- 2026-09-25
- Engine
- SeerForecast
Win+$486
Why this call
- What the analysis said
The largest company reporting this week and its strongest bear signal. Est. annual return -22.6%, well inside the strong-bear band, on a Blended P/E of 43.43 against a Normal P/E of 30.06 (44% above). With the macro gate not in force, the valuation case is enough to act on. The structure fits the name: options price a 3.53% move for this report, while Costco's average reaction over the last eight quarters has been 1.42%. A call spread sold just outside the priced move collects that gap and needs only that the stock not rally 4% in one session. The short strike also sits just below the 20-day ($935.65) and 50-day ($939.72) averages, which the stock has been trading under. There is a live margin question too: Costco said in May it would pass tariff refunds back to members rather than keep them, and the stock fell about 4% that day. Active cash-secured put selections: none on this ticker.
- Risk: This is a short against a company that does not miss. SeerAI score, the 1Y miss rate is 0%, and Costco has matched or beaten estimates in each of the last five quarters. Consensus looks for $6.51 to $6.56 of earnings per share against $5.87 a year ago on revenue of about $94.85B, and August comparable sales rose 8.4% (6.9% without gasoline and currency). The stock is also already 15.9% below its 52-week high, so part of the de-rating has happened. The way this loses is a clean beat plus a membership or capital-return headline that re-rates the stock back toward its averages in one session. That is why it is Tier 2 and one contract.
- Execution gate: the short strike is placed at the implied move, per the rule. If the live implied move on Thursday is above 4%, move both legs out to keep the short call beyond it. Skip below $1.90 of credit on the 15-point width.
- How it was picked
Rule-based screen agreed. The rule-based screen selected this ticker and structure independently that week.
- Signal class: Bear
- Valuation vs its own normal P/E: +44%
- Policy in force that week
1 of 12 lessons active that week named this play.
- bear-debit-put-structure-downgrade: Bearish debit structures (Bear Put Spread) into earnings lost on every settled episode while the credit Bear Call Spread on the same ticker and week won, so downgrade any short-side thesis expressed as a debit put structure and prefer the call-credit expression.
CTASBear Call SpreadBearishTier 3 - Strikes
- $208.74 / $213.71 modeled
- Entered
- 2026-09-22
- Expiry
- 2026-09-25
- Engine
- SeerForecast
Win+$322
Why this call
- What the analysis said
The second-strongest bear signal on the calendar. Est. annual return -20.0% puts it in the strong-bear band, on a Blended P/E of 38.69 against a Normal P/E of 26.26 (47% above), with forecast growth of 11.4% that does not justify the premium on its own. The macro gate is not in force, so valuation is allowed to carry the thesis. The pending UniFirst acquisition ($310 a share in cash and stock, about $5.5B of enterprise value) is the fundamental question the quarter has to answer: Cintas itself says it becomes accretive only by the end of the second full year after closing, so near-term guidance has to absorb the dilution. The structure asks only that the stock not rally 5% in three sessions. Active cash-secured put selections: none on this ticker.
- Risk: Two things hold this at Tier 3 and at two contracts. The 1Y miss rate is 0% and SeerAI score, so this is a short against one of the best execution records on the calendar, and estimates have risen into the print (consensus $1.36 against $1.20 a year ago, up from $1.32 ninety days ago). A clean beat with an unchanged full-year guide is the likeliest outcome and should leave the stock inside the short strike. A beat with a raise, or a faster accretion timeline for UniFirst, is how this loses. The stock also sits about 14% below its 52-week high of roughly $229, so it is not an extended multiple going into the print.
- Execution gate: we could not confirm a live implied move before publishing. The short strike assumes roughly 4.5%, so check the live figure Tuesday and keep the short call at or beyond it. Skip if the live credit is under $0.60 on the 5-point width rather than moving the short strike toward spot.
- How it was picked
Rule-based screen agreed. The rule-based screen selected this ticker and structure independently that week.
- Signal class: Bear
- Valuation vs its own normal P/E: +47%
- Policy in force that week
1 of 12 lessons active that week named this play.
- bear-debit-put-structure-downgrade: Bearish debit structures (Bear Put Spread) into earnings lost on every settled episode while the credit Bear Call Spread on the same ticker and week won, so downgrade any short-side thesis expressed as a debit put structure and prefer the call-credit expression.
PAYXBull Put SpreadBullishTier 3 - Strikes
- $108.23 / $105.94 modeled
- Entered
- 2026-09-22
- Expiry
- 2026-09-25
- Engine
- SeerForecast
Loss−$2,000
Why this call
- What the analysis said
A real discount on a company that does not miss. SeerAI score, a Blended P/E of 20.57 against a Normal P/E of 25.57 (20% below), and a 0% 1Y miss rate. The est. annual return is flat at +0.2%, which is a directional reading and would normally mean no play. A bull put does not need direction. It needs the stock not to fall more than 5% in three sessions, and a company that has not missed in a year, trading below its own normal multiple, clears that bar on most prints. The bar is modest: consensus is $1.32 of earnings per share against $1.22 a year ago on revenue of about $1.63B, in line with a full-year guide of 5% to 6% revenue growth and 8% earnings growth. The stock goes in soft, 4.3% below its 20-day average ($121.32), after a 3.9% drop on September 8. Active cash-secured put selections: none on this ticker.
- Risk: The flat forecast is what caps this at Tier 3, and it is not nothing: the model sees no return from here, so the case is entirely about the discount and the execution record. The real risk is small-business employment. Paychex's revenue moves with the number of paychecks its clients run, and a soft employment read or a cautious hiring comment on the call is the one thing a perfect beat record does not protect against. Cintas reports the same morning on the same customers, and sits on the other side of this book.
- Execution gate: we could not confirm a live implied move before publishing. The short strike assumes roughly 4.5%, so check the live figure and keep the short put at or beyond it. Skip below $0.28 of credit.
- How it was picked
From the written analysis. The weekly analysis made this call. The rule-based screen did not select this ticker and structure that week.
- Policy in force that week
1 of 12 lessons active that week named this play.
- bull-debit-call-structure-downgrade: Bullish debit structures (Bull Call Spread / Long Call) into earnings lose at a far higher rate than credit Bull Put Spreads across the entire sample, so downgrade any long-side thesis expressed as a debit call structure and prefer the put-credit expression.
SNXBull Put SpreadBullishTier 2 - Strikes
- $264.86 / $256.94 modeled
- Entered
- 2026-09-23
- Expiry
- 2026-09-25
- Engine
- SeerForecast
Loss−$284
Why this call
- What the analysis said
The week's strongest bull signal. Est. annual return +21.2% with forecast growth of 16.2%, a 0% 1Y miss rate and a 45% beat rate. The last quarter was a clean beat: $4.85 of earnings per share against $4.14 expected, on revenue of $19.57B, up 31%, driven by server demand for the AI buildout. The company then guided this quarter to $4.25 to $4.75, above where the street was, and consensus has settled at about $4.64, inside that range. The stock is at $260.26, above its 50-day ($254.13) and 200-day ($232.30) averages but 12% below its 52-week high of $296.47, so it is not going in extended. The short put sits 8% below spot. Active cash-secured put selections: none on this ticker.
- Risk: The multiple is the caveat that holds this at Tier 2. A Blended P/E of 14.91 against a Normal P/E of 10.94 is 36% above normal, and SeerAI score, so the stock has already been re-rated from a low-margin distributor toward an AI-infrastructure name, and a quarter that shows the server business slowing would un-rate it fast. The second risk is the one this year's AI-infrastructure prints have taught: these stocks trade the margin line more than the revenue line, and a big revenue number on thinner margins can still send the stock down.
- Execution gate: we could not confirm a live implied move before publishing. The strike assumes roughly 7%, so check the live figure Wednesday and keep the short put at or below it. Reprice both legs off Wednesday's close, not the September 17 reference, and skip below $0.95 of credit.
- How it was picked
From the written analysis. The weekly analysis made this call. The rule-based screen did not select this ticker and structure that week.
- Policy in force that week
1 of 12 lessons active that week named this play.
- bull-debit-call-structure-downgrade: Bullish debit structures (Bull Call Spread / Long Call) into earnings lose at a far higher rate than credit Bull Put Spreads across the entire sample, so downgrade any long-side thesis expressed as a debit call structure and prefer the put-credit expression.